By Fraser Duncan
Time to read: 4-6 minutes
The below information is provided for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Recent case law from the Court of Appeal for Saskatchewan highlights the trend toward longer reasonable notice periods under the common law in Saskatchewan for long-term employees subject to without cause termination. In Saskatoon Minor Basketball Association v MacDonald,¹ and Korpan Tractor and Parts (Parriwi Management Inc.) v Denton,² the Court of Appeal upheld Court of King’s Bench decisions awarding notice periods of 22 months and 24 months for employees whose employment was ended after 16.5 years and 24 years respectively.
The calculation of common law notice can be extremely consequential to long term employees whose employment has been ended by their employer without just cause and where the employment contract did not expressly specify a period of notice. Statutory notice periods, such as those in section 2-60 in The Saskatchewan Employment Act, represent only the baseline: common law notice will typically exceed statutory notice and, for long term employees in particular, the difference can be very significant as the maximum notice under The Saskatchewan Employment Act is only eight weeks.
The factors determining the length of common law notice are well-established. Following the seminal Bardal v Globe & Mail Ltd. case,³ Canadian courts look to the character of employment, the length of service of the employee, the age of the employee, and the availability of similar employment in relation to the employee’s experience, training, and qualifications. While other circumstances may, on occasion, be relevant to the determination of the notice period, the Bardal factors remain the principal basis for the notice calculation. Longer notice periods are generally warranted where the terminated employee is older, has worked for many years for the employer, will likely struggle to find similar employment, and/or worked in a higher-ranked position with greater responsibilities. Comparisons with cases with similar facts are helpful, but judges have recognized that “no two cases are identical; and, ordinarily, there is no one ‘right’ figure for reasonable notice.”⁴
In Saskatchewan, the upper end of the range of common law notice, generally awarded in cases involving senior executives beyond middle age, had long been understood to be eighteen months.⁵ The decisions in MacDonald and Korpan indicate that this is no longer the case.
In MacDonald, Justice Bardai reviewed a number of relevant wrongful dismissal cases and concluded that “over the past two decades there has been a gradual increase in the amount of reasonable notice courts have been prepared to award.”⁶ On the basis of the facts found by the trial judge, the award of 22 months’ notice was, according to Justice Bardai, “on the higher end of the range” but “still within the appropriate range.”⁷ The Court also rejected the other arguments advanced by the appellant employer,⁸ leading to the dismissal of the appeal as a whole.
In Korpan, the appellant employer argued, among other things,⁹ that the trial judge applied by rote an earlier decision in which a plaintiff was also awarded 24 months, that the trial judge failed to consider other cases with more analogous facts, and that the trial judge failed to properly consider the availability of similar employment factor. However, Justice Schwann, writing for the Court of Appeal, disagreed, finding that the trial judge was “alert to the requisite considerations” and that the assessment of reasonable notice was neither based “aimlessly…[on] an anecdotal rule” nor the rote application of the earlier case. Moreover, Justice Schwann emphasized that the question of weight to be given to the various Bardal factors is a matter of discretion for the trial judge. As the assessment of common law reasonable notice is a “a fact- and context-specific exercise,” the trial judge’s decision was entitled to deference.¹⁰
Key Takeways
The judgments in MacDonald and Korpan do not mean that the assessment of reasonable notice damages will increase for all plaintiffs who successfully bring an action for wrongful dismissal. The calculation of reasonable notice remains very much guided by the factual circumstances in each case and the application of the Bardal factors.¹¹ However, for older employees terminated without cause after many years of service and with limited prospects of finding similar employment, the decisions indicate that the upper end of reasonable notice range is higher than had been previously understood.
¹ 2025 SKCA 42 (CanLII) [MacDonald].
² 2026 SKCA 44 (CanLII) [Korpan].
³ 1960 CanLII 294.
⁴ Minott v O’Shanter Development Company Ltd., 1999 CanLII 3686 (ON CA) at para 62.
⁵ Wankling v. Saskatchewan Urban Municipalities Association et al., 1989 CanLII 4625 (SK QB) at para 41.
⁶ MacDonald, supra note 1 at para 38.
⁷ Ibid.
⁸ The Court rejected arguments regarding the decision having been made by summary judgment, the status of the plaintiff as an employee and not an independent contractor, the mitigation efforts of the plaintiff, the sufficient of reasons provided by the Chambers judge, and the award of costs to the plaintiff.
⁹ The case is also noteworthy for the Court of Appeal’s discussion of whether the respondent employee resigned or, alternatively, abandoned his position, whether the respondent employee had complied with the duty to mitigate, and the legal principles related to deductions from the damages award.
¹⁰ Korpan, supra note 2 at para 59.
¹¹ Note that common law entitlements can be displaced by negotiated terms in an employment contract. It is critically important to seek legal advice on the likelihood and amount of recovery when considering a severance offer and/or potential litigation.